Castle Rock's Favorite Handmade Pies

I'm Justin, the Mile High Pie Guy, and I bake each pie by hand right here in Castle Rock using the freshest ingredients possible.

Pick from the classic Blueberry, the zesty Cherry or the much-loved Caramel Apple, all showcasing my signature flaky crust. Every pie is handmade and baked with devotion for you and your loved ones to delight in.

Customer Testimonials

  • Mrs. Murri

    We've been getting pies from The Pie Guy for about a year now and they are ALWAYS top-notch! Every flavor, EVERY time is completely delicious. We usually just order for ourselves, but anytime we've brought a pie with us to a family gathering, it's always a hit. If you are looking to have a homemade tasting pie, but with all the professionalism, these pies are the pies for you too!

  • Beth

    We ordered a Strawberry Rhubarb and the pie was EXTRAORDINARY!! LOVE IT!!! A+++ on the crust.

  • Ella

    I don't normally like pie, but OMG are these pies good!! I have tried several different kinds now and all of them are my favorite.
Submit a Testimonial
Order Your Fresh Pie Today!