Castle Rock's Favorite Handmade Pies

I'm Justin, the Mile High Pie Guy, and I bake each pie by hand right here in Castle Rock using the freshest ingredients possible.

Pick from the classic Blueberry, the zesty Cherry or the much-loved Caramel Apple, all showcasing my signature flaky crust. Every pie is handmade and baked with devotion for you and your loved ones to delight in.

Order a Pie

This year, you can find me at The Festival Park Farmers Market as usual, but I'm also expanding to The Parker Farmers Market. Two locations, same handmade quality. Check the schedule below to see where I'll be, then order ahead to reserve your favorite flavors.

  • Festival Park Farmers Market

    300 2nd St, Castle Rock, CO 80104
    Sundays ~ 9AM - 2PM

    Dates I will be there

    • May 24
    • June 7th, 14th & 28th (Ducky Derby)
    • July 12th & 26th
    • August 9th & 23rd
    • September 6th & 20th
    • October 4th & 18th (Fall Festival)

  • Parker Farmers Market

    19565 Mainstreet, Parker, CO 80138
    Sundays ~ 8AM - 1PM

    Dates I will be there

    • May 17th & 31st
    • June 21st
    • July 5th & 19th
    • August 2nd, 16th & 30th
    • September 13th & 27th
    • October 11th & 25th

Market Selections

Our most popular pies, featured at markets weekly. Reserve ahead to secure your selection—availability is limited.

Customer Testimonials

  • Mrs. Murri

    We've been getting pies from The Pie Guy for about a year now and they are ALWAYS top-notch! Every flavor, EVERY time is completely delicious. We usually just order for ourselves, but anytime we've brought a pie with us to a family gathering, it's always a hit. If you are looking to have a homemade tasting pie, but with all the professionalism, these pies are the pies for you too!

  • Beth

    We ordered a Strawberry Rhubarb and the pie was EXTRAORDINARY!! LOVE IT!!! A+++ on the crust.

  • Ella

    I don't normally like pie, but OMG are these pies good!! I have tried several different kinds now and all of them are my favorite.
Submit a Testimonial